TOPIC: 2019 Reprinted Token Suggestions

Fiddy wrote: I'm saying that a 1-handed martial-only weapon shouldn't have the same damage as one usable by all classes (at the Relic level).

That's the problem with Thor's. You could say the same thing about Viper's offensive classes should have more avg damage then the sword and board. The hole is already there and I don't see it being fixed until all the average damage goes up (aka power creep).

Ed

MasterED wrote:

Fiddy wrote: I'm saying that a 1-handed martial-only weapon shouldn't have the same damage as one usable by all classes (at the Relic level).

That's the problem with Thor's. You could say the same thing about Viper's offensive classes should have more avg damage then the sword and board. The hole is already there and I don't see it being fixed until all the average damage goes up (aka power creep).

Ed

I don't disagree. I was just giving my reason for not wanting to see the Relic sword reprinted as-is, even though I'm open to other Relics being reprinted. Rather than reprint the sword, there will likely need to be a different 1-handed weapon Relic for the martial classes (at some point). And yes, power will creep forward yet again.

Ok, rather than do this myself, I figured I would try something else.

How about a doodle poll, where everyone can enter?

I will update the first post with this link as well

doodle.com/poll/86g2zvrpvt9g63z6

This poll has yes, if needed, and blank as options.

I would like to have everyone fill out only the ones they want as yes, as needed if you would be ok with it but aren't requesting, and blank if you would vote against.

I am also open to suggestions on how to do this better.

If there are requests I missed, please let me know and I will add them on to the end.